Thursday, 13 March 2014

White Whales (Part Five)

A world where superhumans have changed the course of human history. 

A world of conflict, and consequences. 

A world gone mad.

The world of WILD TALENTS.

I have been a fan of Greg Stolze's One Roll Engine game system since its first iteration, in the gritty World War II superhero game GODLIKE. In an era where most of the popular games looked a lot alike (the all-d20-all-the-time early 2000s), the One Roll Engine was something fresh and exciting. It had the bloody, unforgiving level of detail you'd find in an old-school military game like TWILIGHT: 2000, but wrapped up under the hood of a sleek new Ferrari ready for you to push the pedal all the way to the floor. It also had Dennis Detwiller's long and detailed history of the war, ready to be tinkered with by superhumans with powers greater than the average Joe (while still refreshingly mortal). 

WILD TALENTS is the GODLIKE timeline spun forward to the modern day, with a revamped ORE under the hood and a badass coat of paint by Todd Shearer. Not only did it improve on the rules of the original and provide us with almost 70 years of new history to set our games against, it provided a robust toolkit (by luminary Ken Hite) for designing your own superheroic histories and creating gritty superhuman dramas of your own. Any one of these elements alone could have been the spine of a great game, but together...? 

You can almost hear that engine purr.

I've played a lot of superhero games over the years, and Stolze's game mechanics are among the tightest I've ever seen. There is enough flexibility in power creation to make highly detailed and fidgety powers, or the ability to make them simple and broad - garnish to taste. Although the default mode of the game is for gritty realism, which could leave heroes a little on the bloody and battered side at the end of a fight, there are a number of built-in tweaks that can adjust the game into more of a "four colour" mode. Either way, it plays FAST.

Most of the effort in the game is frontloaded on character creation, which is as complex (or simple) as you'd like it to be. There are also nifty goon rules so that the GM can throw a horde of unlucky, low-powered crooks at the heroes for a thorough whomping. Unless, of course, one of the mooks gets in a lucky shot...

Although the WILD TALENTS timeline is an excellent starting point for creating alt-history supers games, with a number of ready-to-play campaign concepts in the book associated with interesting historical moments (which could become more interesting yet, with the presence of superhumans in the mix), I have to admit that creating my own games is what really excites me. Ken Hite's "Four Colors" system is an excellent benchmark to use when creating your own superhuman histories, breaking down some important ideas about how the usual flow of history might change and how the game will feel thematically. There are also several published settings for the game, including the sensational Victorian KERBEROS CLUB book by Ben Baugh. 

I created two pitches for Wild Talents games last year, INSURGENCY and TRUE BELIEVERS, which I talked about here. One is a rock-em-sock-em "What If The Villains Won?" adventure where the heroes are struggling to overthrow an army of triumphant villains. The latter is more down-to-earth, examining some of the obsessive nature of superheroism through the lens of "real life superheroes". It speaks to the power and breadth of WILD TALENTS that it could handle both of these games with style. 

I've been considering what the One Roll Engine could do with a pulp game, if I were to use it instead of Fate (which I had always considered my go-to pulp game engine since SPIRIT OF THE CENTURY). But I'd also be game to just sit down together with a group of players and let them play with the toys themselves, to build a new supers world together. 

Now that would be wild.

Monday, 10 March 2014

White Whales (Part Four)

While we're talking about Jonathan Tweet, let's talk about his other great 1990s game (one could argue that ARS MAGICA also qualifies, but I'm afraid I can't speak to that one) EVERWAY.

EVERWAY makes an interesting counterpoint to OVER THE EDGE. While the latter is contemporary, surreal, and focused on the small dramas of the obsessive exiles in Al Amarja, the former is mythic fantasy, drawing on classical storytelling modes, and its stories are played out against the largest possible tapestry -- "Discover the fates of a thousand worlds" is the game's tag line. Both feature robust character generation systems that tend to produce unique, rich characters, and a cosmopolitan attitude -- encountering people of different cultures is a core part of each game. 

The thing that makes EVERWAY special, and alas, probably means we'll never see its like again, is that both character generation and task resolution in the game relies heavily on imagery and interpretation. An integral part of character creation is to draw five cards from a deck of images that reproduces a wide range of fantasy paintings (which are remarkably broad in their depiction of different races and cultures) and use them to tell the story of your character's life up to the beginning of the game. Clearly, this was an expensive proposition -- one that only Wizards of the Coast, in the early 90s "rolling in dough like Uncle Scrooge" days could have ever afforded to bankroll. Task resolution uses a Tarot-style "Fortune deck" that tells you subjectively how Fortune plays a part in the outcome of events.

Unfortunately, the things that make EVERWAY great probably also prevented it from finding a larger audience. Roleplayers are a parochial lot at the best of times, and in the early 90s a diceless fantasy game that did not include classes, equipment, detailed spell rules, or support for classic dungeon-crawling action was not long for this world. I found mine in the bargain bin at Capitaine Quebec, a great comic store in Montreal that dabbled for a time in RPGs. For a while, you could find copies of the boxed game sets and the "vision cards" that were used to build characters for very little money. Me and a few friends were able to secure copies fairly cheaply. So many years down the road, I think it might be a lot harder. 

I have run EVERWAY on several occasions, and we've always had fun with it, but I've never really run that big, ambitious campaign that the game practically demands. It is a game that requires some adjustments on the part of players and also of the GM, in that it doesn't do classic combat-heavy fantasy roleplaying well. A great EVERWAY game feels a lot more like a fairy tale or a myth, and indeed the heroes are intended to start at a very high level of power compared to most games. Spellcasters in this game can literally start out as the most powerful wizard in the world, if they want. How many other games let your sorcerer start out as Gandalf or Merlin, or let your warrior have the strength of Hercules? This is heady stuff, and for a GM who's used to more constrained fantasy romps, it can be tricky to adjust your thinking about challenges and such. 

The resolution system in the game might make some people fear the clammy grasp of GM fiat, and I would say that's true (in fact, I would say that is one of the game's strengths - the lineup to hit me with lead pipes for this heresy forms to the left). The cards in the fortune deck represent broad ideas in narrative, and each card has a "positive" and "negative" meaning depending on whether it is oriented up or down. In a way, this is very simple -- you can pretty much tell whether things go well or poorly depending on what the card says. The different ideas associated with the cards make this somewhat subjective, however, and what exactly success or failure might include will likely vary wildly from one GM to another. I think the modern way to deal with the fortune deck would be to play the cards in the open, and occasionally put the interpretation of the card to the player it affects. "Okay, based on that card, tell us how you escape from the collapsing temple." 

The basics of a setting are included with the game -- the city of Everway itself, a kind of fantasy-mileu Cynosure (see my piece on GRIMJACK) which is at the center of the universe -- connected by the Walker's many gateways to a thousand worlds (or Spheres, as they are known in the game's cosmology). The gate-travelling heroes (also called Spherewalkers) use this city as a kind of base of operations for their exploration of the multiverse, and the GM can use it as a place for recurring characters and intrigue outside of missions to various Spheres or travels for personal reasons. There are short seeds for many different Spheres the characters can visit, and more were detailed in the long-out-of-print SPHEREWALKER SOURCEBOOK by Greg Stolze. (I regret that I did not purchase it, the one time I saw it available for sale. Sigh!)

One day, my path through the Spheres will lead me back to Everway...

Friday, 7 March 2014

White Whales (Part Three)

The coffee shop is small, dim, smoky. The ceiling fan only stirs the murk, and the heat of noon fills the cafe, making the American sweat. His hands are shaking a little when he lifts another Turkish cigarette to his lips, taking a deep drag, trying to keep it together.
The little man in the fez seems to appear from nowhere, taking the seat opposite the American without invitation. He is wearing a greying noose around his neck, a local affectation that puzzles the American. The little man smiles, exposing a mouth full of rotten yellow teeth and gunmetal grey fillings. 

"What's your pleasure, Mr. Cotton?" he says, his voice pleasant, obsequious. But there is a cruel edge underneath it.

He knows what the American wants.

He knows..

*     *     *     *     *

So begins a visit to the tiny Mediterranean island nation of Al Amarja, a place that most of the world doesn't even know exists. But for the few who come here -- the seekers who cannot find what they need anywhere else -- Al Amarja is a promise. Here, nothing is true, and everything is permitted.

OVER THE EDGE, Jonathan Tweet's sublimely strange RPG about this tiny island (which bears more than a passing resemblance to William Burroughs's Interzone), is a game about obsession. About people who are after something they can find nowhere else on earth. For some, it is drugs, for some sex, for some inspiration. For others... their heart's desire, no matter how bizarre or unearthly, might be found here in the teeming barrios of The Edge. The air is thick with conspiracies, the water poisoned with secrets, the food tastes of mysterious spices, and ghosts walk the streets. 

Unlike some of the games on this list, I have run this particular White Whale on several occasions. The light rules, which encourage outre characters and creativity, fit me like a glove, but I never felt like I mastered the setting and uncovered the rich core of dark gaming goodness that lurks within OTE. Here is a game that demands players and a GM who are as driven and obsessive as the characters they play. A troupe that are willing to take the game down strange alleys, smoke exotic herbs that grow only below the ancient Pyramids, and open their minds to a world of surreal danger. 

A group willing to take their game to the edge... and beyond.
 
 
Footnote: The opening scene is a homage to the introductory scene in Clive Barker's HELLRAISER, which is pretty much the best part of a not-very-good movie. I thought the portrayal of Frank's quest for sensation leading him inevitably to the Lament Configuration and the Cenobites was a perfect encapsulation of the obsession that drives OTE characters.

Thursday, 6 March 2014

White Whales (Part Two)

Monster games don't usually appeal to me. The various editions of VAMPIRE have always left me cold, and CHANGELING is fascinating, full of cool ideas, and ultimately baffling to me in terms of gameplay. (I like the portrayal of the Faerie Courts in the Dresden Files books a lot more than the White Wolf incarnation.)

I guess ultimately I prefer games that are about characters who are the good guys, and I'm not much interested in telling stories about characters who aren't motivated by the better parts of human character. In the end, those guys can always walk away from any trouble that's too inconvenient, while a good guy -- a hero -- always has to make a stand. Characters who care about things (and people) are just better foundations to build a story on.

Something about WEREWOLF: THE FORSAKEN keeps drawing me in, however.

Maybe it's the epic mythology that frames the game, where modern werewolves can trace their lineage to an Edenic prehistory where the world of flesh and the world of spirit were one. The werewolves -- the shape-changing progeny of the mighty spirits Father Wolf and Luna, thus the children of both the physical world and the spiritual, able to change their forms at will -- are forever condemned for a terrible crime committed by their mythological forebears. When Father Wolf grew old and weak, unable to fulfill his duties, he was killed by his werewolf children -- because in all things, the tribe must come first. This caused a great sundering, breaking the connection between the two worlds. Now the descendents of those primal wolves carry on the duty of policing the borderlands between, keeping spiritual predators in the physical plane from preying on the weak. But the spirits have never forgotten the werewolves' original act of patricide, and they are forsaken by the spirit world and the human world alike -- born of two worlds, but belonging in neither. 

Maybe it's the theme of rage and violence underlying the Uratha (the name werewolves call themselves) that makes this a spicy treat. Their intentions may be duty and honour, but Uratha tend to solve their problems with tooth and claw, and they're always struggling to rein in their savage nature. It's good to have a hero with Size 13 feet of clay. 

Maybe it's the thought of all the things I could do with the spirit realm that the Uratha can travel into, a shadowy reflection of our world where ordinary things and places take on eerie significance. The Host, creatures that are half-mortal and half-spirit, like the werewolves, provide a creepy nemesis -- half-human rat and spider-things lurking in the dark places of the city looking for prey. 

Or maybe it's just the lure of being an awesome werewolf. Racing under the full moon as a wolf, following the scent of your prey through two worlds, and tearing into your enemies with wild abandon. 

It would be a game with both a contemporary urban edge and tribal mysticism, equally at home in a world of seedy honky-tonks, urban wastelands, dense primal forests, soaring mountainsides and the dazzling dreamspace of the spirit realm. 

Maybe I'm just howling at the moon...?

Wednesday, 5 March 2014

White Whales (Part One)

I suppose every GM has their list. The games that they've always wanted to run, the ones that keep drawing them back, taunting them, because they've never been able to run them. At least, not to their satisfaction.

Up until a few years ago, I had a few more things on my list of GMing "White Whales" -- including a post-apocalyptic game, a Victorian adventure, and a Shadowrun game. I've been lucky enough to run those games and finish them to my own satisfaction, but I've still got a number of games that I've never managed to conquer. 

Let me tell you about them, faithful reader, then we can cry into our beers together and curse the churlish indifference of players (and the fact that there are never enough hours in the day, it seems). 

The thing at the top of my list is not a game, it's a genre. 

PULP!

Oh, how I love pulp. I love the era of men wearing fedoras and hot jazz and cars with rumble seats. I love heroes that solve their problems with science, a cocky grin, and a good right cross. I love villains who relish a dastardly plot, a doomsday device ticking down to zero, hapless victims tied to railroad tracks, and a smug moustache-twirling monologue. I love gangsters with weird deformities and mad scientists with dodgy robots and I love rocket packs carrying the hero to the rescue. I love spunky reporters and men of mystery and dashing pilots and two-fisted academics. I love zeppelins and domino masks and Nazi-punching, oh yes.

"But," the pedants wheeze, "that isn't what the pulps were. Your intelligent apes and mole machines are revisionist heres--"

*BIFF* "That's all for you, palooka. Give my regards to your dentist." 

I've been trying to get a pulp game to fly for almost a decade. I thrilled to the pulse-pounding pages of White Wolf's ADVENTURE!, rallied to the fated flag of SPIRIT OF THE CENTURY, and longed to join the HOLLOW EARTH EXPEDITION. Sure, I've run successful short subjects, but never that big, satisfying multi-reel epic you need a big bucket of popcorn for. I have glimpsed the glory of MASKS OF NYARLATHOTEP, but been forced to turn away before my face was properly melted. 

I love the purity of the genre, which has equal time for heroes that solve problems with blazing .45's and scientific messiahs who rarely kill and dream of an earthly utopia. I love the atmosphere of the era, the fashion, the big cars with running boards and the Art Deco towers. I love the optimism and the sense of exploration, as bold men and women began to fill in the few uncharted places on the map and scientists began to build the modern world we know. 

I love Indiana Jones and The Rocketeer and Doc Savage, the menacing Shadow, the rollicking Phantom, and the mysterious Green Hornet and Kato. They're calling my name.

Pass me my fedora, will ya? 

Sunday, 2 March 2014

Another Bug Hunt!

I was recently exploring ideas for running an ALIENS themed game online, as a drop-in game for those nights when my regular Monday group can't all be there. Everybody can grok a straight-up Colonial Marines game full of tense exploration in darkened corridors, punctuated by bursts of furious combat. And James Cameron's entry in the series still maintains much of its power, almost 30 years on. (I imagine a lot of nerds read that last line and were suddenly acutely aware of their grey hairs -- I know I was while writing it.)
I found John Harper's outstanding Colonial Marines hack for Apocalypse World, THE REGIMENT, which I highly recommend to anyone who likes that ruleset. That was excellent, but a bit too crunchy for what I've got in mind. There's also Gregor Hutton's sublime storygame 3:16 CARNAGE AMONG THE STARS, which appends clever character-building through flashbacks onto dead-simple mechanics. Perhaps a bit too simple, but I haven't entirely given up on it.

In retrospect, it's amazing that over the years there have been so few games that tackled the "bug hunt" niche, although maybe the truth is that movie licenses are expensive and most people just come up with their own hack as needed. I can think of the Amazing Engine supplement BUGHUNTERS, and the official ALIENS game (I think that was late 80s / early 90s) from the same guys who did Phoenix Command. That one was likely too crunchy for me. Of course, there's always SPACE HULK, though I never had the means for that (despite loving GW's games), and the tabletop 40K space marines games. 

I found that ideas for an Aliens-themed game came easily, and the world of the "xenoverse" seems closer than ever these days. Modern soldiers are beginning to field equipment on the battlefield that looks an awful lot like a Colonial Marine's kit, and drone weapons are eerily reminiscent of the sentry guns (for those of you who have seen the extended cut of ALIENS). Weyland-Yutani only looks more and more like a modern multinational (which is to say, Big Evil) corporation, much like a spacefaring descendent of Halliburton. I've seen technical demonstrations of devices that look an awful lot like early runs at the big yellow Power Loader that Ripley uses to lay a whuppin' on the xenomorph Queen. 

What sorts of things would Marines do when they weren't dealing with bugs, I wondered? Pacifying breakaway colonies and political uprisings seems likely, and I can easily picture religious factions and anti-corporate groups being a factor in a spacefaring culture where huge megacorporations are so chummy with the government (for all we know, they are the defacto government). 

I also started imagining an enemy faction that descends from rogue androids, the Meks. (It's easy enough for your thinking to end up on killer robots when you start down the James Cameron primrose path.) These would be androids who shrugged off their programming, much like the replicants of BLADE RUNNER, to create very dangerous terrorist cells. The first generation Meks ritually remove their skin, to reject the appearance of their human oppressors. Second generation Meks are custom-grown to look non-human, with an appearance much closer to the "greys" of UFO lore. Third generation Meks are entirely robotic, with some looking very Terminator-esque and others looking entirely non-human. 

A galaxy full of threats like this, in addition to the usual creepy crawlies and corporate goons, could present a lot of play opportunities. 

Who wants to strap on a smartgun and jump in the dropship? Your express elevator to hell awaits.

Game over, man! GAME OVER!

Wednesday, 26 February 2014

Art and Roleplaying (Part Three)

Back to the questions:

Could a roleplaying game be Art? Should it? 

According to my modest definition of the term, let's see if a roleplaying game could fit. The first consideration is Craftsmanship. I think the fact that I'm writing a column about roleplaying establishes that for some of us, we put a great deal of thought into the techniques involved in the hobby, and indeed the possibilities that tabletop roleplaying presents as a narrative/performance medium. Look at great books like Graham Walmsley's PLAY UNSAFE and Robin Laws's HAMLET'S HIT POINTS, which consider the medium from the performance and narrative perspectives, and you'll likely agree that there are at least a handful of people in the hobby who really do think about the craftsmanship involved in a good game. 

Content. Although not all roleplaying games are going to fulfill this requirement, beyond perhaps exploring the human condition through the experiences of several characters, there are certainly games that explore central themes -- Kagematsu and gender, for example, or the way Tribe 8 explores religion. I also think that the improvisational nature of the medium means that some of the themes that evolve do so organically, through play and development, rather than as an "authorial intention" of the GM and players.

Audience. This is one of the things that makes roleplaying games unique, in that the artists and audience are the same people. Does that count? I would argue that it does. Roleplaying games don't make good spectator sports, in my opinion and experience, but there are many times over the course of an average session when a player is called on to pay attention to scenes where other players are playing out a scene, as opposed to acting in it himself. I have presented the idea previously that a high-functioning roleplaying group has much in common with jazz musicians, playing together and building on the riffs that each person brings into the mix, using the central song (the game rules would be the analogy here) as a springboard for personal expression. An improv theatre company probably operates in much the same way. 

So I think it's possible, according to this definition, to see a roleplaying game as Art. But should it be Art? 

This brings us full circle to the beer and pretzels guys, looking askance at anyone bringing deeper meanings into their goofing around, and the bashfulness that a lot of players feel for attaching that highfalutin word to the hobby. This, I think, is a problem not of the word or the hobby, but of perception.

People that don't like the word Art seem to think of Art as something remote, exalted, intellectual. Surely you couldn't call something that's fun and entertaining Art? Surely someone who's sitting at a kitchen table, possibly with a handful of dice close at hand, shouldn't be called an artist? 

But Art isn't just a word that describes dusty, fussy old statues in museums and experimental theatre performed by people in black turtlenecks. Art can be a crowd-pleaser, like Shakespeare or Martin Scorsese, or sublimely weird and sometimes goofy like Salvador Dali or David Lynch. Art is a window into a part of the human experience, the imagination, the spirit. It tells us something true about the world and about ourselves. 

I like roleplaying games that are full of laughs and goofiness. I like to roll dice and eat Doritos and drink beer. And I'm okay with the idea that a lot of people are going to scoff at the notion of roleplaying games as Art. I get that people don't think of themselves as Artists, even if you reassure them that Artists are people who eat Doritos and drink beer and enjoy goofing with their buddies too.

But I have played games that were full of powerful dramatic moments, like a good stage play or a televison show or a novel or a movie. I've walked away from the table some nights emotionally spent, exhilarated, sad, my head boiling with ideas. Just exactly what happens when I've enjoyed an effective piece of Art. 

You can call it bad Art, or low Art, or whatever you want. You can call it pretentious nonsense. 

But why not call it Art? Why not be an Artist?