I've been doing a lot of thinking lately about running a pulp adventure game. My friend Rob talked me into the idea in these very pages, when I waxed rhapsodic about the genre and its siren call. It was energizing to finally have a player that was excited about pulp, because I've been trying to sell it to groups for many years.
I was a big fan of White Wolf's wonderful ADVENTURE! RPG, which had a metric ton of inspiration even if I didn't care for the ruleset so much. I was an early adopter of SPIRIT OF THE CENTURY, although I must admit that it too served more as a tease than a window to pulpy adventures -- I used the early incarnation of FATE inside to run many things over the years, but rarely what was advertised on the cover.
There have been others: HOLLOW EARTH EXPEDITION is a beautiful book with all kinds of awesome in it, but it's wrapped up in a system that's a little too fiddly for my liking. The core "use any die you want" mechanic of Ubiquity is great, but there are just a few too many geegaws welded onto that elegant frame. SAVAGE WORLDS has a lot to like about it, and a generally pulpy tone, but it's way too swingy for my liking. And I never did find an alternative to the "Shaken" rules that easily fixed the issues I have with a player being sidelined during combat, possibly for a long while.
Bearing in mind the above, I had a bear to wrestle now that I'd finally made the decision to run a game in this genre. What rules to use? You might think the answer would be obvious: SPIRIT, or some more modern version of Fate (such as the excellent FATE ACCELERATED EDITION, which is now my go-to Fate game). Usually, you'd be right, but having just come off running two games using Fate in the last six months, I'm ready to run something different. I had already decided -- before I'd actually settled on a subject -- that my next game would not, could not, be Fate. Sorry, Evil Hat guys, I love you and your game a lot, but papa needs a little vacation from Aspectville USA.
After leafing through a number of games on my shelves, during which I briefly considered MUTANTS & MASTERMINDS (lovely, but too much of that system would be unnecessary for what I've got in mind) and WILD TALENTS (the default mode is too gritty for pulp), I settled on the lovely and simple PDQ system as it appears in SWASHBUCKLERS OF THE 7 SKIES. PDQ feels like a distant cousin of Fate, and should be a good fit for the group and the subject matter without a lot of heavy lifting. I still have to read the version of PDQ included with TRUTH AND JUSTICE (the superhero incarnation of that ruleset) to see if there are tweaks I want to make with the rules.
The next step was to decide on an angle with the material that would be cool. I remembered all the cool stuff in the above books, and especially Jess Nevins's STRANGE TALES OF THE CENTURY, a glorious supplement for SotC that explores a lot of the most important archetypes (and briefly catalogues the real-world pulp characters who fit into them) and, more importantly, places them in historical context against a global backdrop spanning the thirty-plus years of the pulp era.
Which era would I use? The Roaring Twenties? The Dirty Thirties? The war-torn Forties? The Fifties seemed less likely, but perhaps there was some juice there (although Indiana Jones's latter-day Commie-fighting adventures left a thoroughly bad taste in my mouth). Maybe there was a way to combine them all in one sprawling, Nazi-punching narrative?
Stay tuned for the next pulse-pounding chapter!
Wednesday, 16 April 2014
Tuesday, 8 April 2014
It Ain't All Gold
High Trust, High Drama play has rich rewards, it's true, but there are also sometimes problems. The one I'm thinking about today is the disconnect that sometimes exists between the players involved in a scene and the other players who are the audience.
For a player that's deeply into character, a scene can feel "true" and worthy even when it doesn't "play" to the rest of the room. That is, at the end of the scene no particular progress has been made -- no character has asked anything of the other, no particular conflict has been stoked or even acknowledged.
In the abstract, this is fine. Sometimes, it feels necessary to play out little pieces of connective tissue in a story even when they're not in the business of resolving a conflict or forwarding the overall plot. Except that these little pieces can end up eating up a substantial amount of "screen time" in a session. When a scene that's not about anything other than the immersion of the players in their characters eats up ten or twenty minutes (or more) of time, that's not only not moving the game forward, it's actively taking time away from more productive scenes.
It's an explicit part of the social contract for a HTHD game that other players serve as audience for the scenes that they're not in. In a situation where players are actively trying to escalate the drama, this is fine -- scenes crackling with conflict are fun to watch. But if that's not happening, the other players are twiddling their thumbs. Long scenes where nothing happens is asking a lot of your fellow players. Chances are, they've got something more pressing they would like to be pursuing for themselves if they got a chance.
Try to imagine a television show or a film that contained a twenty minute scene where nothing at all happened. Unless the dialogue was particularly crackling, you'd probably turn the channel.
It is also true of the theatre that sometimes a scene that feels "true" to one of the actors involved in it doesn't play at all below the footlights. In that case, it's the director's job to coax a performance to life. In a tabletop game, that's a more tricky situation -- a GM that tries to cut a scene short risks upsetting his players, or worse, cutting off a player who's getting to a petition or some kind of reveal, but taking a while to find the right words or moment.
Finding the "second pause" in a scene can be an instructive way of looking for a place to stop (I think that was a piece of advice from SMALLVILLE) -- literally listening for the second time that the characters have a break in their conversation often means the players are searching for things to say. If that's true, it's probably okay to cut away to something else or at least suggest doing that.
I guess what I'm arguing for here is sensitivity -- both on the part of the "audience" and the "actors" in a scene. The actors need to try to keep scenes where there isn't anything pressing happening between two characters short. If it's running longer than five minutes, you may be indulging yourself in something that's not that interesting to everyone else at the table. And, to be fair, often players know going in when there's an active conflict and when there isn't -- you likely know that when someone calls for the scene.
The audience needs to try to gently nudge things when a dead scene is dragging on and on. Remember, the cardinal rule is that everyone at the table is entitled to participate and enjoy themselves (adjusted for meanings of "enjoy yourself" which include tortured character drama, naturally). If two players are eating up screen time, it's fair to expect them to do something with it. And it's also good policy to try to nudge a scene to a conclusion or toward a conflict rather than just cutting it off abruptly. Sometimes good things happen late in a scene, if you're patient.
And, above all, don't try to launch into an at-table discussion of what should be happening in the scene. This is the worst possible resolution, cutting the acting players out of their immersion in the roughest possible way and imposing the group's ideas on people who may not want them at all.
Encouraging other players to come to a point or cut it short is one thing. Armchair quarterbacking a scene you're not in is just plain not cool.
For a player that's deeply into character, a scene can feel "true" and worthy even when it doesn't "play" to the rest of the room. That is, at the end of the scene no particular progress has been made -- no character has asked anything of the other, no particular conflict has been stoked or even acknowledged.
In the abstract, this is fine. Sometimes, it feels necessary to play out little pieces of connective tissue in a story even when they're not in the business of resolving a conflict or forwarding the overall plot. Except that these little pieces can end up eating up a substantial amount of "screen time" in a session. When a scene that's not about anything other than the immersion of the players in their characters eats up ten or twenty minutes (or more) of time, that's not only not moving the game forward, it's actively taking time away from more productive scenes.
It's an explicit part of the social contract for a HTHD game that other players serve as audience for the scenes that they're not in. In a situation where players are actively trying to escalate the drama, this is fine -- scenes crackling with conflict are fun to watch. But if that's not happening, the other players are twiddling their thumbs. Long scenes where nothing happens is asking a lot of your fellow players. Chances are, they've got something more pressing they would like to be pursuing for themselves if they got a chance.
Try to imagine a television show or a film that contained a twenty minute scene where nothing at all happened. Unless the dialogue was particularly crackling, you'd probably turn the channel.
It is also true of the theatre that sometimes a scene that feels "true" to one of the actors involved in it doesn't play at all below the footlights. In that case, it's the director's job to coax a performance to life. In a tabletop game, that's a more tricky situation -- a GM that tries to cut a scene short risks upsetting his players, or worse, cutting off a player who's getting to a petition or some kind of reveal, but taking a while to find the right words or moment.
Finding the "second pause" in a scene can be an instructive way of looking for a place to stop (I think that was a piece of advice from SMALLVILLE) -- literally listening for the second time that the characters have a break in their conversation often means the players are searching for things to say. If that's true, it's probably okay to cut away to something else or at least suggest doing that.
I guess what I'm arguing for here is sensitivity -- both on the part of the "audience" and the "actors" in a scene. The actors need to try to keep scenes where there isn't anything pressing happening between two characters short. If it's running longer than five minutes, you may be indulging yourself in something that's not that interesting to everyone else at the table. And, to be fair, often players know going in when there's an active conflict and when there isn't -- you likely know that when someone calls for the scene.
The audience needs to try to gently nudge things when a dead scene is dragging on and on. Remember, the cardinal rule is that everyone at the table is entitled to participate and enjoy themselves (adjusted for meanings of "enjoy yourself" which include tortured character drama, naturally). If two players are eating up screen time, it's fair to expect them to do something with it. And it's also good policy to try to nudge a scene to a conclusion or toward a conflict rather than just cutting it off abruptly. Sometimes good things happen late in a scene, if you're patient.
And, above all, don't try to launch into an at-table discussion of what should be happening in the scene. This is the worst possible resolution, cutting the acting players out of their immersion in the roughest possible way and imposing the group's ideas on people who may not want them at all.
Encouraging other players to come to a point or cut it short is one thing. Armchair quarterbacking a scene you're not in is just plain not cool.
Saturday, 29 March 2014
As Tears Go By
So, I cried in character at the table last Saturday night.
Yeah. That's never happened before.
Anecdote:
My wonderful wife has a great part time job where she acts as a
"standardized patient" to train medical students, and she's able to
reach down somewhere and cry in character at the drop of a hat. It
freaks young doctors out pretty good to deal with that sort of real
human emotion. They often have a hard time believing that it's an act,
even though she can walk out of there smiling and comes home feeling
refreshed.
We're an uptight lot in Western society,
uncomfortable with public displays of emotion -- or maybe with being
confronted by the fact of a stranger's humanity, vulnerability, their
struggles. It's a lot easier to deal with the world when you imagine it
as an anonymous mass of ciphers than as a teeming hive of people each
with their own particular problems and hopes and dreams. We get very
good with dealing with the surface of the world, and not venturing too
far below that.
So it is in roleplaying games. For the vast majority
of people in the hobby, their characters are statistics and bonuses
wrapped around a nugget of personality, some wisecracks, and whatever
backstory makes it to the table. "Playing in character" seldom means
more than speaking in a slightly different voice.
Even for those of us who are inclined toward
roleplaying in a dramatic mode, it's usually a restrained affair.
Although we're aiming for situations that are tense and dramatic, and we
encourage each other to commit to scenes that go deeper than an
ordinary RPG would, it's understood that performance may be felt more deeply than it is seen
by the audience of other players -- so much so that I have written here
about the occasional need for literally breaking into third person to say what a character is feeling.
I think I'm a pretty good actor at the table, as far
as these things go, although I'm not sure I've got a huge range. I can
do things with my voice that show how I'm feeling better than some, even
if the subtleties of expression around my mouth are obscured by a
beard. But most of the time, although I'm able to be "in the moment" and
in the head of my characters, I don't go that deeply into
characterization that I'd be able to produce that strong an emotion at
the table.
What was different this time? I'm not sure. I think
this was an important moment for my character, who was trying to hold it
together and be strong for his family and friends -- who are, to be
fair, fighting with the devil for their very souls. His sister, however,
has been fighting a different fight, and last episode was finally
losing her struggle with AIDS in an era that barely knew what to call
the disease. Although they've scrapped more than their fair share
throughout the series, he has a deep attachment to his sister, and feared losing her again. More than that, feared that she would die
hating him (which he probably deserves) -- essentially rejecting him for
all time.
The tears came when he was pleading with his sister
to let him be there for her when she died, and to tell him when the time
had come -- not to run off again and perhaps disappear into the
wilderness. "I don't want you to die alone in the woods, like an
animal..."
Megan was pleased with this, and always encourages
my actorly leanings, although most of the time I consider my theatre
days long behind me. I think it was strong medicine for the other player
in the scene, and I hope it wasn't an uncomfortable thing for others at
the table. Like I said, people aren't used to this sort of thing in public. Even as a pretend thing.
I'm not sure how I feel about it. I don't know what
brought me to that moment, exactly, and whether I'll have others like it
or if it that was just a momentary crack in my emotional armour. I
wasn't afraid of that reaction, or embarrassed (as an adult I have less
invested than I once did in pretending aloofness), and it's pleasing to
be moved by your character on a personal level.
Thursday, 20 March 2014
Generosity (Part Three)
More than any other player at the table, the GM is regularly called upon
to play a generous role in the game. In a significant sense, that is their
function at the table -- to provide support as necessary for player
character development and play a provocative role when development needs
some help to move forward.
The moral of the story is, while you should
certainly take Graham Walmsley's advice and Play Unsafe, another thing
you should always try to do is to Play Generous. (Generously? You get
the idea.)
I have written recently about my belief that the GM's
position should be a reactive one, with most of the focus being on
actively paying attention to the players and providing them with what
they need in a scene. As the player outside the overall narrative thrust
of the game, the GM is in a unique position -- required to
provide generous moments to players, really, because the game is not
about the development of NPCs. This is the biggest part of the GM's
responsibility, to be there to push the right buttons at the right
moments to achieve the effects the players are after.
In a game with a high-functioning group, this is what every player at the table should be striving for.
Does
that mean that, in a group that's firing on all cylinders for dramatic
play and sharing that juicy narrative control around, a GM isn't
necessary? Well, perhaps. Let us say that a skilled GM is less necessary
when there are enough others around who are taking up the slack. I'm
not sure I'm ready to say the GM's day is done, if the players are good
enough, but that may be my own gamer baggage talking.
Tuesday, 18 March 2014
Generosity (Part Two)
Generosity is an important part of the complex harmonies that make up
drama. It is the thing that bridges the distance from two actors
performing in the same place and performing together.
To be continued...
Generosity is what makes acting more than the sum of its parts.
So what does this mean for roleplaying?
There
are at least a few games out there that explore the dramatic side of
roleplaying -- I'm specifically thinking of PRIMETIME ADVENTURES and
Robin Laws's DRAMASYSTEM, although I'm sure there are others I'm not
remembering. These games are generally good at explaining the essence
of drama, which is (as David Mamet would have it) placing two
characters who want something in a scene together, knowing that they
both can't get what they want, and then watching what happens.
PTA models conflicts between characters (large and
small) in an efficient way, and DRAMASYSTEM introduces the important
idea that it's necessary for players to concede to each other for drama
to proceed, rather than digging in their heels and refusing to give.
While both of these games stake out territory that is the foundation of
drama, neither really gets into the business of how to make drama at the
table that functions at a higher level.
In essence, what we're talking about here is
communication, so perhaps it's fair to say that these games assume
Generosity is something that's a social contract issue, rather than
something that should be prescribed by the game itself. That may be
right.
It's so important for a group that's interested in
playing a dramatic game to work on those basic skills -- not only
developing their own ability to perform and play proactively at the
table (driving their character's development and wrestling with
conflicts) but listening to other players actively. This is essential
not only for the well-being of the game as a whole, but for playing
dramatic scenes with the other characters. If you know what someone's
deal is and where they're going with their storyline, you're ready to
not only interact with them but to be generous with your scenes, helping them build at the same time you're pursuing your own goals.
You're operating on several levels at once, like
those high-functioning actors I talked about: you're performing your own
character, building the overall structure of the game, and providing
assistance to your fellow player at the same time.
What we're talking about here, in other words, is
for each of the players at the table to take some of the authorial power
and responsibility (the latter being the important thing, with regard
to generosity) that the GM traditionally held at the table. Although a
lot of modern games talk a good show about shared narrative control, the
"sharing" part is often limited -- players get a say in how their
problems shape up, or are encouraged to add glosses to the scene as it
unfolds, or the rules themselves focus on player decisions shaping
narrative. In other words, they often have more to do with the power part of the GM role, not the responsibility part; players can throw things in the mix to taste, but there is no requirement that they play well with others.
Monday, 17 March 2014
Generosity (Part One)
Let's talk about techniques this week.
An actor needs to be constantly present in a
scene, listening to and watching the other actor's performance, to
create that back-and-forth which makes a scene really cook.
Specifically, let's talk about Generosity.
Megan and I were talking about this recently, and it spilled over onto
Episode 7 of the podcast, but I want to explore it a bit more here.
Actors talk about generosity in terms of playing a
scene with another actor. It's the sense that the other actor you're in a
scene with is giving you support for what you're doing, and helping you
set up emotional beats for your performance. In other words, the actors
playing a scene together are thinking about several things at once:
first, of course, the prescribed words, movements and actions that make
up playing the scene; secondly, a general knowledge of what's happening
in the play and what must be communicated within the scene to move
things forward; and thirdly, an awareness of not only what the actor
herself is trying to do, but what the other actor is trying to do at the same time.
Although some people like to talk about actors as
little better than trained monkeys who repeat the lines they're given,
there is a very complex interplay at work in a scene between two actors
who are really working together at a high level. Like musicians, they're
communicating back and forth, adjusting their performances to be in
harmony with, and building on, each other.
It's true of many actors that they may be skilled
but not generous, and their performance is entirely self-contained,
without that level of communication and interaction that really takes a
performance to another level. An un-generous actor isn't thinking about
what they can do for the other actor, only about their own performance.
This leads to situations where a strange discordance is created, and
actors have reactions that don't seem to make sense in a scene -- a
sudden turn to anger, for example, when the "supporting" actor hasn't
done enough to provoke that reaction.
Next, I'll talk about what the implications of this are for roleplaying.
To be continued...
Saturday, 15 March 2014
White Whales (Part Six)
It seems appropriate to end this series with a series of items that are all of leviathan stature.
It
is a sad truth of gaming as an adult that you simply don't have the
time to invest in the hobby that you may have had as a teenager or a
university student. In the halcyon days of yore, it was a delight to
spend a summer whiling away the days playing a whole, lengthy campaign
from start to finale in a matter of weeks. Nothing gives you the same
feeling of dense narrative as a big, meaty adventure campaign like the
sort that were common in the days of first edition D&D and which
endure, after a fashion, for the Call of Cthulhu RPG.
Playing a campaign game like that has weight,
like tackling a big novel. Players that share an experience playing
through it often remember it fondly, trading war stories like old
soldiers.
For me, one of my formative experiences as a gamer
was the epic D&D campaign which would later be christened QUEEN OF
THE SPIDERS. My early D&D group fought through a series of
adventures, first the trilogy AGAINST THE GIANTS, then the long pursuit
for those pulling the strings of the giant invasion -- culminating in
the journey to the VAULT OF THE DROW and the extraplanar finale, QUEEN
OF THE DEMONWEB PITS. What can you say about an adventure series that
ends with a head-on battle with a demon-goddess?
It was unforgettable. The sort of thing that sells you on the hobby for life.
I
would later try to resurrect this campaign as part of my long-running
FORGOTTEN REALMS campaign in Kingston (you'll have to forgive me the
heresy of moving the adventures from good old Greyhawk). As I have
lamented elsewhere, the lightning could not be captured twice. Although
that game ran long and had many pleasures, the players never fought
Giant One. The rumours of the giant invasion and its masters went
unexplored, as the players pursued their own interests in the City of
Ravens Bluff.
Ah well.
The other purveyor
of epic campaigns is Chaosium, whose Call of Cthulhu game remains a
tried and true favourite of myself and many others. I've run a shorter
CoC game called HORROR'S HEART, set in 1920's Montreal, which was fun
but not quite of the same scope as some of the real "doorstops" in the
Chaosium catalogue. I played through a campaign of AGAINST THE
BROTHERHOOD one summer, providing a lifelong bond between me and the two
other players who survived that time-bending epic, but I have never had
the opportunity to follow that up by running the pulpy masterpiece
MASKS OF NYARLATHOTEP.
Who could resist a romp around the globe punching
sinister cultists and visiting exotic ports, culminating in --- well, I
wouldn't dream of spoiling it, except to say that it's the sort of thing
that makes me smile from ear to ear just thinking about it.
I actually went so far as to write a trailer for
this game last year, but alas, my beloved wife has no truck with the
Elder Gods or their nihilistic ilk. It was and will be a non-starter.
The cultists will remain unpunched and the murder of Jackson Elias will
go unavenged.
Pity.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)